Clone journals, often referred
to as mirror or replica journals, are works that resemble authentic scientific
journals by using their names, logos, editorial boards, and even their website
designs. These clone publications, however, are dishonest and don't adhere to
the required ethical and intellectual norms. Without offering enough peer
review or quality control, they seek to lure researchers into submitting
publications and paying publishing fees
Although it might be
difficult to distinguish between clone journals, there are certain
characteristics that could indicate their fraud:
Website Design and
Quality: Websites for clone journals sometimes have formatting issues, broken
links, and grammatical problems. Additionally, they can be lacking crucial
knowledge on the journal's scope, editing procedures, or publication policies.
Editorial Board Members:
Verify the editorial board members' identities and affiliations as indicated on
the journal's website. Without their knowledge or approval, well-known
researchers or experts may be included in clone journals. Verify the board
members' participation by separately contacting them and cross-checking their
affiliations.
Lack of Rigorous Peer
Review: Even though clone journals may make this claim, their peer review is
frequently ineffective or nonexistent. Genuine journals adhere to a strict
peer-review procedure to guarantee the caliber and reliability of published
publications.
Excessive Publication
Fees: Numerous times, clone journals demand expensive publishing fees without
offering sufficient editorial assistance or services. To decide whether the
journal's fees are appropriate, compare them to those of other respected
journals in your field of expertise.
Inclusion in Blacklists:
Numerous organizations keep databases or blacklists of known clone or predatory
journals. To determine if the questioned journal is included, look through
these resources.
Avoid publishing in clone
journals at all costs since they lack credibility and risk damaging your
reputation as a researcher. Before submitting your work, always do a thorough
investigation and confirm the legitimacy and reputation of the journal. Select
renowned, well-established publishers with strict peer review procedures and
open publication policies. Getting advice and essential information about
selecting reputable journals can also come from talking to coworkers, mentors,
or respected authorities in your industry.
1 Comments
Really appreciate writer. It is very informative. Good Job!
ReplyDelete